top of page

ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY

'Fine Line'
cover + track list

Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
maxresdefault.jpg
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png

'Harry Styles'
cover + track list

Harry_Styles_-_Fine_Line.png
76901038_2834746449890692_3691060238091288576_o.webp
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-07 at 2.48.57 PM.png

 Annotated Bibliography

Sheffield, Rob. “Harry Styles BRINGS Rock-Star SWAGGER, Pop Joy to Madison Square Garden.” Rolling Stone, Rolling Stone, 26 June 2018, 2:50 p.m., www.rollingstone.com/music/music-live-reviews/harry-styles-brings-rock-star-swagger-pop-joy-to-madison-square-garden-665907/

      This article was extremely helpful for my topic of  Harry Styles and showing how he has successfully established his solo career. Rob Sheffield has given a full concert review from a 2018 show in Madison Square Garden. He opens the article with a quote from Harry during the show, “Please feel free to be whoever it is you choose to be in this room tonight”. Rob then goes into detail about how Harry ‘takes his own advice’ and wraps himself in a rainbow flag and a bi pride flag while singing. He then points out the various ways that Harry has changed his stage presence since his days of being in One Direction.

      This article recounts almost every aspect of a typical Harry Styles: Live On Tour concert from 2018. Rob writes about Harry’s enthusiasm, charisma, his voice, guitar, crowd interactions, and even his flared Gucci pants. He also talks about the two extremes of Harry’s loud rock songs like ‘Kiwi’ compared to his softer guitar songs like ‘Sweet Creature’. He relates it to ‘Mick Jagger’s yin and Paul McCartney’s yang’ and talks about how this concert takes the fan’s mind off of the troubling events that were going on in America in 2018.

      I do believe that this article was meant to provide an honest review of the concert for the reader. Rob does a really good job of capturing the feeling of being at a Harry Styles rock-inspired concert and describes a nice balance between the types of songs on the setlist and the overall look of the band. He also captures the essence of the ‘rock-n-roll’ feeling that was in the air for the reader. This review gives a neutral perspective from someone who is not a die-hard fan for the reader.

Cox, Jamieson. “Harry Styles: Harry Styles.” Pitchfork, Pitchfork, 16 May 2017, https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/23204-harry-styles/

      In this article, Jamieson Cox gives a bit of a harsh review of Harry’s first album, Harry Styles. He goes through the tracklist song by song, and lists both positive and negative aspects about each of them. He makes essentially the main point of the article to be about the fact that each song ‘references’ a song from 20, 30, or 40 years ago. He plucks out an old song and compares it to Harry’s for every single track. Although this critic didn’t give the album the highest score, he does mention positive aspects about Harry’s voice and overall vocal range. He also makes it a point to appreciate Harry’s nod to classic rock-n-roll songs and compliments his enigmatic persona, despite previously being a member of one of the biggest bands in the world.

      It may seem a bit backwards to include this source in this project, but I actually found it incredibly useful for the points I wanted to make about Harry’s first album. The author helps prove the idea that the majority of older listeners and critics picked apart Harry’s first album and chalked it up to ten songs that do nothing more than reference old ones. I wanted to touch on this side as an opposition or ‘another view’ for the later parts of this project. Compared to other articles, it doesn’t speak super highly of the album, but it provides fantastic insight about what critics were saying about Harry Styles in 2018, touches on his enigmatic persona, and talks about the room for growth in his writing that he eventually brought into his second album. While it’s not bashing on Harry, it allows for the reader to see a negative opinion on Style’s work. If someone only read this review and never heard the album, they would not have the most positive opinion on his music.

Officialbeatsmusictv, director. Harry Styles - Zane Lowe 'Fine Line' Interview. YouTube, YouTube, 22 Nov. 2019, www.youtube.com/watch?v=dGG1UZNp4-A.

      This video is a highlight reel of some clips from an interview between Zane Lowe and Harry Styles regarding the release of his second studio album, Fine Line. This video contains a lot of important points that I wanted to include in this project from Harry himself. When asked if he could hear differences between his first and second album, he said yes. He mentions that he felt he was playing it safe with the first album out of fear that he wouldn’t impress the world as a solo artist. He then talks about how he has evolved as a writer into a writing process that was fun and more authentic to his true self. He also compares what the meaning of success was between his first album and second album. Lastly, he goes into the redefinition of success throughout the process of writing Fine Line and how it has impacted his career in a positive way.

      This interview provides a lot of key points that help aid my main theme of the evolution of his career. From One Direction to his solo career, it shows how he has evolved his song-writing capabilities into his own path instead of fighting for space between the four other artists of his band. Compared to other interviews, this one is a rare occurrence where Harry is being raw and vulnerable. He breaks away from his typical answering in circles and opens up about the process of writing his second album. This could be one of the most credible sources considering the answers are coming from Harry himself.

Mylrea, Hannah. “Harry Styles – 'Fine LINE' Review: Packed with Personality and Charm (AND Saucy Lyrics).” NME, 10 Dec. 2019, www.nme.com/reviews/album/harry-styles-fine-line-review-packed-with-personality-and-charm-and-saucy-lyrics-2584779.

      Contrasting to other album reviews, this review of Fine Line is a straight-to-the-point analysis of the changes between Harry’s first and second albums. This article references the fact that Style’s first album might’ve been a bit too heavy on his rock influences, which led him to cloud himself from letting his true ideas shine through. However, it talks about how he has come into his own through Fine Line. The author acknowledges that, while his influences are still evident, he has been able to seamlessly blend them with his own style and sound that sounds more like a modern day rock star and less like an homage to his musical heroes. They also talk about the difference in honesty from the first album, with Harry’s classic quote of the album now being about “having sex and feeling sad” which is not something that was ever talked about for his first album.

      This review shines a bright light on his second album. It also compares it to the negative light that was on his first album. It allows the reader to gain a fresh perspective on Style’s work and gives him credit for the change in his music. This author lets the reader see how each song is appealing in it’s own way, without dressing it up to an annoyingly high extent. They also acknowledge songs that are weaker than others, allowing for the reader to get a raw and honest review of the album.

Dugdale, Paul, director. Harry Styles: Behind the Album. Apple Music, 19 May 2017, music.apple.com/us/music-movie/harry-styles-behind-the-album/1259614011.

      Behind The Album is a documentary that was recorded during the making and recording of Harry’s first album, Harry Styles. The film follows Harry and his team of producers and writers in Jamaica as they write and record the album while simultaneously living in the studio. It offers interviews with Harry, clips from recording, clips of their nightly adventures, a performance of each song, and a nod to his days in One Direction. This film gives the most footage of behind the scenes that Harry has ever allowed in his career and showcases him in a different light.

      This film offers a lot in terms of the way that Harry is portrayed. It shows him struggling to write songs, doubting himself, and the interviewers ask him about very personal questions that have never been asked before. It allows the viewer to see him ‘peel back the layers’ and open up about topics that are new. It showcases him in a more human light, as opposed to an emotionless popstar. It is filmed in a way to show real and raw moments that would have otherwise never been seen by the public. This allows the viewer to form a natural opinion based on real events and honesty.

​

“Harry Styles.” Biography.com, A&E Networks Television, 1 Apr. 2021, www.biography.com/musician/harry-styles.

      This article gives a biography of Harry Styles’s life. He was born in England in a small town with his sister and divorced parents. He attended Holmes Chapel Comprehensive School where he and some of his friends created a small band called White Eskimo. They performed together throughout school until Harry ultimately left when he joined the X-Factor. Styles was almost eliminated from the show as a solo artist, until Simon Cowell put him together with four other boys to form One Direction. Their band went on to become one of the biggest bands in the world, with five albums, four world tours, and dozens of records broken. After the band, he started his solo career and his acting career, with Christopher Nolan’s Dunkirk.

      This biography is strictly informational. The author doesn’t really talk about Harry in a positive or negative light. They use neutral wording and sentence structure. It was meant for the reader to get a background on Styles from an informational point of view. This piece also offers their research in the form of links and photos so that the reader can get an in-depth understanding of the person being described.

Pike, Naomi. “Harry Styles's Latest Gucci Look Is Bigger and Better than His Boa.” British Vogue, British Vogue, 30 Mar. 2021, https://www.vogue.co.uk/miss-vogue/article/harry-styles-gucci-beloved

      This article covers Harry’s most recent appearance in the Gucci Beloved campaign. They describe his latest role as being one of the faces of their newest advertising campaign alongside familiar Gucci faces and new-to-the-family faces. Vogue talks about how this marks the sixth time that Harry has stepped in front of the camera for Gucci and probably not his last. His current and past outfits are described with a nod to Gucci’s creative director, Alssandro Michelle.

      Vogue does a very good job of talking about Harry’s most recent Gucci collaboration with a positive tone. They aren’t bashing any of the people involved or the campaign itself. It is apparent that British Vogue is a fan of Harry’s, seeing as they use expressions like “after his stellar suits and boa at the Grammys” and “charismatic photo of our boy”. While this article is clearly informational, there is an underlying tone of bias and support for both Gucci, and also Harry.

Sheffield, Rob. “The Harry Styles Hit List: A Few of His Favorite Things.” Rolling Stone, Rolling Stone, 29 Aug. 2019, https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/harry-styles-favorite-things-albums-tv-878041/

      This interview-style article was written by Rob Scheffield for Rolling Stone. It gives an artist-by-artist breakdown of Style’s opinions and it just goes down the line until they reach the end. A lot of the content is words from Harry himself, with some other explanations that Rob throws in there. Rob does a great job of storytelling here and filling in the gaps that Harry fails to explain when talking about each artist. They talk about how each artist has influenced Harry or his music, some of his favorite songs, favorite albums, favorite album covers, and experiences that he has had with the artist.

     The way that Rob set up this article is very clean-cut and organized. He spends time going into a bit of detail for each of the 14 songs/artists mentioned. I think that this is super important because Harry’s musical influences are such a big part of who he is as an artist. Helping the reader understand Harry’s background helps them understand him even better, and I think that is exactly what Rob was trying to do here. While he tries to remain neutral, it is pretty clear that he is a fan of Harry’s and respects him to some level. He carries a positive tone and throws a few compliments in here and there. That being said, this article was clearly just meant to showcase the importance of these rock legends to Harry and his music.

“Harry Styles: Fine Line Review – Idiosyncratic Pop with Heart and Soul.” The Guardian, Guardian News and Media, 13 Dec. 2019, https://www.theguardian.com/music/2019/dec/13/harry-styles-fine-line-review-columbia

     The next source I have found is an album review for Fine Line. This was done by Laura Snapes on the day that the album came out in 2019. Her review is generally positive, going into a bit of depth about how Harry’s thoughts are channeled into this album and what they mean. She is one of few critics that has actually mentioned the point of Harry being vague and distant in a way. She states, “Harry Styles’ fanbase haven’t, like most, named themselves in his image, and it’s telling: Styles sometimes seems like the least important part of the package. He’s a blurry focal point, avoiding specific personal or political pronouncements. By vaguely standing for fluidity and tolerance, he creates a space for fantasy that perhaps he has realised is best left undisturbed”. This is one of the major differences between Harry’s last solo work and One Direction, which is odd that it isn’t talked about more often.

     Laura does appear to be talking about Harry and his music in a positive light. After giving the album 4 out of 5 stars, she goes on to talk about the influences behind each song. She makes a comparison between him and Shawn Mendes, stating that if Shawn sang ‘Watermelon Sugar’, it would sound like a Body Shop advert. This makes the review sound just a bit biased in Harry’s favor. She also mentions that whether or not you know who he is singing about, he sells the story very well. While this review is not completely neutral, it is still a great source for this assignment. It is clear that the critic is, at least, somewhat a fan of Harry’s, she doesn’t lay it on too think in a way that makes the reader feel the bias negatively. 

Setoodeh, Ramin. “Harry Styles Concludes Three-Month 'Love on Tour' Trek with Rousing New York Show: Concert Review.” Variety, Variety, 29 Nov. 2021, https://variety.com/2021/music/news/harry-styles-love-on-tour-fine-line-concert-review-1235121190/

     In this concert review, Ramin Setoodeh recounts the final moments of Love On Tour from the last show on November 28th in UBS Arena. He included some quotes from Harry during the show and recounted the final moments of the last song, Kiwi, where Harry restarted it twice to get more energy from the crowd and sang the full song three times, shouting “You’re gonna have to kill me to get me off it!” during the last one. He talks about the stage setup, the water that Harry throws on fans, and the equality between how much time he spends dancing and how much time he spends singing. Setoodeh also talks about how long Harry waited for the tour to even happen, as well as bits from his final emotional speech near the end of the show.

     Ramin Setoodeh’s count of Love On Tour is written in a very neutral tone. While it is clear that he enjoyed himself, he isn’t necessarily praising Harry for every little aspect of the show. On the contrary, he also isn’t bashing him for anything either. This review is clearly from the perspective of someone who went to the show and simply had a good time. There aren’t any judgements or criticisms that take the reader’s attention away from the main point. He talks about Harry in a more positive light, and also shines a little bit of it on the discourse surrounding his fans. 

Sheffield, Rob. “Harry Styles Got Shameless for Harryween, to the Surprise of Literally Nobody.” Rolling Stone, Rolling Stone, 1 Nov. 2021, https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/harry-styles-harryween-madison-square-garden-1251686/

     This article is a concert review from Rob Sheffield about Harry’s two-night ‘Harryween’ concert party in Madison Square Garden this past October. Rob describes both nights in a decent amount of detail. It ranges from Harry’s costume, the band’s costumes, the fan’s costumes, the setlist, and the overall vibe of the evening. Rob also mentions the anticipation of the event, and how it affected the overall excitement of the night. He also mentions some events from the night like Harry speaking to a group of dads in the audience, his portrayal of Dorothy for the first night, some fan signs, and Harry’s interactions with them.

     Rob Sheffield is one of the critics that really just gets it. He nails Harry’s every single time he steps out to critique a show or album. His writing is done in a way that doesn’t feel completely biased towards Harry, but in a way that he knows what he is talking about when it comes to the discourse surrounding him.  By describing specific details from each night, Rob crafts a review that makes the reader feel like they are in the room. He also includes several of Harry’s quotes to bring it all together. It is clear that this review was written for the people who weren’t able to go. While he is speaking about Harry in a positive light, he isn’t being overbearing with it. He creates a perfect balance for the reader to have a positive reaction to his work. I would consider this source to be very credible because the author was actually present for both concerts that he is writing about.

Ferla, Ruth La. “What Harry Styles Fans Wore for 'Harryween'.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 2 Nov. 2021, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/01/style/harry-styles-halloween-costume.html

     This article provides a review of some of the best costumes from Harry’s ‘Harryween’ show in October. The author talks briefly about the event and Harry’s style in the intro before diving right in. The entirety of the article is a very brief interview with each fan about what they are wearing and how it connects to Harry or his vibe. The author provides each fan’s name, age, occupation, home, and a personalized question about their costume. Each person has something positive to say about Harry or his influence on their fashion.

     This article was written with the intention of showing off Harry’s fans’ costumes. It provides a bit of a look into the ways that the fans talk about him or his influence. Who better to solidify his discourse than the fans who helped create it? There is an obvious bias here, considering everyone that is mentioned has paid to see Harry live, so they must be fans. That being said, it tells the reader that Harry’s fans are influenced by Harry’s fashion in a major way. It also tells the reader that the fashion choices made by Harry and his team have seriously helped his fans become more confident in themselves and their choices. This source is very credible, as the fans have some of the most honest comments when it comes to Harry’s discourse. 

Sheffield, Rob. “Review: Harry Styles Is a True Rock Star on Superb Solo Debut.” Rolling Stone, Rolling Stone, 13 Apr. 2020, https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-album-reviews/review-harry-styles-is-a-true-rock-star-on-superb-solo-debut-119736/

     In this Rolling Stone article, Sheffield gives us his inner monologue on Harry’s debut album, Harry Styles. While he does not give this album an overall rating or score, he makes up for it by going into some detail of the tracks and the influences that he can hear behind them. He opens the review by setting the scene for the reader and mentioning how Harry has not taken the typical boy band alumni approach, but gone for the soft rock approach. He, instead offers, “No club-hopping or bottles popping – it’s the after-hours balladry of a 23-year-old star wondering why he spends so much time in lonely hotel rooms staring at his phone”. Then, he explains the intimacy of each song, and points out the relation to some of One Direction’s classics that were written by Harry, and their brief rock influence. 

     I would definitely say that this is a credible source. Sheffield understands the shift that Harry had begun to make for his career. He not only recognizes, but also highlights the new and intimate side of Harry that can be felt throughout the entirety of his first album. This is a major critique in the way that he brings the shift in Harry’s message forward in a positive light. He gives the audience an honest review of the music while pointing out the different route that he is setting himself up for. One of the main themes of this article can be described as telling the reader ‘hey, check out Harry Styles, he’s doing some really cool new solo stuff’.

Crowe, Cameron. “Harry Styles: Singer Opens up about Famous Flings, Honest New LP.” Rolling Stone, Rolling Stone, 22 Sept. 2019, https://www.rollingstone.com/feature/harry-styles-new-direction-119432/

     This article provides an in-depth profile of the ‘new’ Harry Styles from early 2017. Cameron Crowe spends the day with Harry as he talks about his new album, going solo, fame, and tries to piece him together for the fans. During a lot of this article, Crowe works off the idea that there is a lot more to Harry than his popstar persona. He tries to decipher the inspirations of his new album and the personal details that Harry is reluctant to share. Crowe also makes note of the important political issues that arise on the album, and Harry’s thoughts on not abandoning his previous 1D fanbase.

     This article carries a lot of heavy themes about Harry and his musical inspiration. It also shines a light on the shift in Harry’s fanbase and how it compares to his days in the band. Crowe is trying to give the reader one of the first inside scoops of Harry when he started his solo career. He is trying to peel back the layers for the audience and offer some real-world connections between Harry’s music and the fans. Crowe also focuses on the ‘honesty’ that Harry keeps mentioning in his music for the reader. Considering this interview is based off of a recorded conversation with Harry himself, I would consider this to be a very credible source. He doesn’t offer any bias, rather as much information that he can get out of Harry for the reader, whether or not they are a fan.

Blistein, Jon. “Harry Styles Talks Mushrooms, Therapy, 'Fine Line' with Zane Lowe.” Rolling Stone, Rolling Stone, 22 Nov. 2019, https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/harry-styles-fine-line-zane-lowe-916437/

     Blistein offers a quick summary of Harry’s interview with Zane Lowe that was posted to YouTube. He focuses on the notion of Harry speaking about ignoring commercial pressure and focusing on making the album sound fun and free. He also mentions Harry’s exclamation of his redefinition of success for this second album. He also brings up some of the other themes that are mentioned in the video like mushrooms, therapy, vulnerability and cheerfulness.
     I think that this source is intended for the reader to get a recap of the interview without having to sit down for an hour. Although brief, this article hits all of the major points that are brought up by Zane Lowe, as well as Harry’s responses. I would call this credible because it is clear that Jon Blistein watched the video and understood what was being said. He offers a truthful summary for the reader to enjoy.

Bowles, Hamish, et al. “Playtime with Harry Styles: ‘You Can Never Be Overdressed.’” Vogue, 13 Nov. 2020, https://www.vogue.com/article/harry-styles-cover-december-2020

     In this all-encompassing article, Hamish Bowles recounts his day with Harry for his shoot on the cover of Vogue. This, now iconic, cover being the one where he is wearing a dress. The article contains a bit of a biography on Harry and why it is relevant to their shoot. He focuses on themes of Harry’s fashion, his lifestyle, the inspirations behind his second album, and how they compare to his first album. This is another type of article that gives a true insider perspective of a really massive moment in Harry’s career.

     This source was intended to let the reader experience the day with them. He provides details about what they did, what they are wearing, where they are going, what Harry’s car looks like, what his house looks like, Harry’s opinions on wearing a dress. This article offers the reader a raw moment where they pull back the curtain on the hysteria surrounding this cover. There isn’t any obvious bias that distracts the reader from the main point.

bottom of page