












GENRE &
DISCOURSE ANALYSIS


Genre and Discourse Analysis
Harry Styles has been in the center of the pop spotlight for just over a decade. Starting from the ripe age of sixteen, Styles has had his entire life brought into the public eye. From being in one of the biggest boy bands in the world, going solo, breaking gender and fashion rules, acting in movies, and winning a Grammy, he has done it all while the world watched. Because of this, the world has also been able to comment on and talk about his journey through every step of the way. From interviews to gossip channels, documentaries to album/concert reviews, movies to twitter fights, there isn’t a platform on social media that doesn’t know the name Harry Styles. For this genre and discourse analysis, I relied completely on the various forms of electronic media for my research. I have looked at personal interviews with Harry, album reviews, concert reviews, his documentary, and many more. The genres involved in his discourse can be described as Pop, Rock and Soft Rock. There are many authors who mention one or several in their works. I have used these sources to compare and contrast and analyze their overall contribution to the discourse and genres of Harry’s solo career.
The first form of research that I found was two different album reviews for Harry’s first and second albums. Although it is the same artist, these reviews paint Harry’s talent and credibility in two completely different lights. The first review is from Jamieson Cox regarding the first album, Harry Styles. Cox paints a negative picture of Harry as a ‘wannabe Elton John or Mick Jagger’. He describes each track as having too much of a nod to Harry’s musical heroes, and not enough of his own personality and overall flair. Cox takes it upon himself to relate all ten songs on the album to a hit song from anywhere between 20 or 40 years ago. He makes this connection to provide the feeling of a lack of originality throughout the album. Without listening to the album, this review alone is enough to paint it in a negative light as a work that lacks creativity, originality and talent. His tone feels almost snarky and mocking Harry’s decisions.
In stark contrast, Hannah Mylrea delivers an honest and more positive review of Harry’s second album, Fine Line. While she is not writing about the first album, she does reference it in the beginning of the review and offers an explanation for the negative reviews surrounding it. She paints it in a different light, mentioning that the pressure of going solo might have played a part in the creation of the first album. Myleria offers a bit more forgiving tone with a willingness to be more open to the music. She showcases the situation in a more human aspect, diving into the fact that he might’ve let his rock influences cloud his own creativity a bit. This review is far more enlightening and forgiving regarding his work. Mylrea goes on to talk about each song of Fine Line individually, pointing out the growth and change in Harry’s honesty, lyrics, and overall composition of his music. Her opinion is generally positive, pulling out the hopeful and honest aspects of the work that she is examining, as opposed to mocking it.
While both reviews are very different, they are similar in one way. While Cox spends most of his time bashing the lack of creativity in Harry’s work, he mentions his respect for his talent and nods to his rock-n-roll influences. He also acknowledges Harry’s personality that shines through, and his boldness for choosing this route. Cox also takes the time to build context for the reader, explaining the differences in the musical route that Harry chose to take. Mylrea also does a bit of the same. She notes that, while his rock influences are not hard to miss, he has brought his own voice into the mix, offering a more positively ending critique for the reader. Despite the differences in reviews, both writers do seem to keep some sort of overall positivity in mind. While it is clear that they have differing opinions about the music that they are reviewing, they make sure to build context, back up their opinions, and help articulate it in a way that is still respectful to the artist.
The next form of research that I gathered was more about an actual outlet, rather than a specific form of media. Rolling Stone has written several articles on Harry or things that he has done. The genres and discourse that come from their articles are always interesting and honest, regardless of the author. The first article that I wanted to discuss was from Rob Sheffield. He gave his audience a review of Harry’s first album on the day that it was released. Similar to the review from Cox, Sheffield takes a minute to discuss the musical route that Harry had taken. He highlights the ‘Rock over typical Pop’ route and gives his feelings about it. Rob goes on to provide his impressions of the details behind each track and each of the influences that he can hear behind them. Rather than just bashing or loving up the album, he provides the reader with a lot of historical musical context to fall back on. He created an aura of credibility with the reader, as it is clear that, not only did he listen to the album, but he put a lot of genuine thought into his opinions and why he felt certain ways.
Rob also dissects the overall tone of the album, stating, “No club-hopping or bottles popping – it’s the after-hours balladry of a 23-year-old star wondering why he spends so much time in lonely hotel rooms staring at his phone”. This helps contribute a lot of new information to Harry’s discourse as a solo artist. He helps to showcase a more raw, emotional, and intentional side to Harry’s music that might not have been written about during the time of the band. He also helps to bring the Rock/Soft Rock genre into the conversation by relating several musical influences back to specific stars of that particular genre.
Also from Rob Sheffield are two concert reviews from separate shows at Madison Square Garden. The first being from Live On Tour in 2018 and the second being from Love On Tour in 2021 on ‘Harryween’. In the first review, Rob really does not hold back on a single detail. He provides a descriptive recount of the entire show that makes the reader feel like they are also witnessing everything. He talks about the parallels between the loud Rock songs versus the more quiet and intimate songs. Harry’s enthusiasm, charisma, voice, instruments, outfit, and crowd interactions are also mentioned. He uses all of these key points to argue that Harry’s stage presence had completely changed from his days in the band. I do believe that this particular article had a generous hand in moving Harry’s discourse in a positive direction.
The second review of Harryween follows a similar pattern. Rob spends a lot of time going into immense detail of the entire evening. He describes Harry’s costume, the band’s costumes, the fan’s costumes, the changes in the setlist, and how everything affected the vibe of the night. He also talks about the anticipation of the event due to being delayed from Covid. He included several quotes of Harry’s from throughout the night and the fan reactions.
In each article, it is clear that Rob is trying to highlight the Rock genre along with the Rockstar status, without being too overbearing. In the first one, he is very descriptive about every little detail that goes on in the arena. He mentions the meaning behind Harry’s words, the crowd interactions, the political flags on stage, and the relation to the political climate of 2018. In the second review, Rob continues his specific descriptions and anything else that he picked up on. His articles are written in a way that doesn’t serve any sort of bias in favor of Harry or his music. That being said, his detailed recounts and explanation on his feelings make him a very credible source for the reader. It is very obvious that, not only did he attend the show, but he paid attention to everything for his article the next day. He creates this balance where the reader doesn’t have to feel like a superfan to appreciate the concert that he is speaking about.
The next Rolling Stone article comes from Jon Blistein. He wrote a short summary article of Harry’s interview with Zane Lowe. Although brief, this article does cover most of the major points that were talked about in Zane’s hour-long interview. Jon writes in a way that is seemingly neutral towards Harry and his music. It feels like the article was written with the intent of summarization and light explanation. Even when writing about topics such as psychedelics, therapy and vulnerability, Jon does not have any negative words to say. This similar underlying tone of respect can also be felt through Cameron Crowe’s article about creating Harry’s profile (also from Rolling Stone). His article contains a lot of heavy themes about Harry’s music, fanbase, political opinions, and personal life. While his article is focused on ‘peeling back the layers’ of Harry Styles, he is still very neutral and respectful towards him. In contrast to Blistein’s article, it is clear that Crowe is working more towards an ‘inside scoop’ for the audience. It contains a written interview with Harry, which I believe deems him to be a credible source. Crowe showcases the raw and vulnerable conversation, without adding too many bells and whistles to make the reader have a different opinion.
The final article from Rolling Stone comes from Rob Sheffield entitled ‘The Harry Styles Hit List: A Few of His Favorite Things’. In this interview-style article, he gives an artist-by-artist breakdown of Harry’s favorite sounds and how each of them makes him feel. They mention several individual artists, groups, specific albums or songs. This article plays a major hand in stimulating the Rock/Soft Rock genre surrounding Harry’s music. The artists that are showcased are some of the older classic Rock artists or their albums. Rob goes into great detail asking Harry specific questions about each one and how they relate to his music. This article really helps put Harry’s name into this genre because of how specific it is. This is the only topic in this article; what influences his music and why. It provides fans with an insider look at the musical inspirations behind each song or album idea. Rob organized the article very clearly, offering a title for each artist, followed by a picture and a brief description of Harry’s answers to his questions. All in all, this article provides a major piece of context to Harry’s musical evolution, discourse, and genre as a whole.
As a whole, Rolling Stone has played a massive part in building context, genres and information when it comes to Harry Styles. Each of their articles appear to be very credible and inviting for the readers. I would even go as far as to say that they are writing for a fan audience, rather than the general public. Each article gets very specific when building context, recounting a concert, or talking about the genre that Harry has moved into. They have helped push his discourse towards the Rock/Soft Rock genres naturally, without any sort of overwhelming bias to turn the reader away.
The next type of media that I consulted was video-style interviews. Since it was mentioned in Rolling Stone, I figured I would consult the actual Zane Lowe interview video to see how it would compare. This interview offers a lot of insight on the subject of Harry’s (then) upcoming album and the inspirations behind it. Seeing as the setting was Harry’s backyard, it allowed for a lot of vulnerability and honesty to be shown throughout the interview. Zane asks a lot of questions that are deeply personal, but still being conscious of prying too much into Harry’s life. His questions are very analytical towards the songs that he chose to zero in on. This paired with the close-up angles of the cameras gave for a very honest interview. There isn’t any sort of bias in Zane’s questions and they are set up in a way that is obvious that he is genuinely interested in what he’s asking. This interview helps bring out the newfound vulnerability that can be seen throughout Harry’s discourse. It feels very unguarded and is organized in a way that showcases Harry’s answers in a very neutral light.
The next example of video-style interviews came from Harry’s documentary, Harry Styles: Behind the Album. This documentary offers a huge abundance in terms of context and discourse. The main point of this film was to give fans an insider look at how Harry’s first album was created in Jamaica , along with an interview and performances of each song. It offers a chronological storytelling of how each song was crafted together. It features clips from writing sessions, recording sessions, moments of Harry and his fellow creators partying, and a personal interview that carries on throughout the entire film. The way that it is set up gives the fans a sort of all-encompassing experience. It shows a bit more of an uncensored domestic side to Harry and his career. The interview provides context to certain scenes as they play and contributes to his overall discourse. This film works to separate the notion of Harry in the band versus Harry as a solo artist by portraying him in a very honest light.
The next two forms of media that I found were a Fine Line review from The Guardian and a Love On Tour review from Variety. From The Guardian, Laura Snapes follows a similar interview formula that I found in my previous research. She highlights certain songs from the album and gives her overall opinion while mentioning the musical influences that she found. However, she mentions Harry’s fanbase in a way that I had not seen before. She highlighted his fanbase and their actions in a way that is essential to Harry’s discourse. Seeing as his fans are a massive part of his celebrity status, Snapes was the first writer that I found to be highlighting this aspect of his career in a positive light. While many writers are quick to dismiss any connection between fan and artist, Snapes not only makes one, but takes the time to dive into the importance of that connection and how it produces an effect on Harry.
After seeing what Snapes had to say about that fan/artist connection, I wanted to find another source. Ramin Setoodeh reviewed the final show of Love On Tour in Long Island for Variety and mentions similar topics. After mentioning the music and instruments, Setoodeh talks about the importance of the stage setup. This conversation helps to build context for, not only the article, but for the entire tour for his audience. He also makes note of the amount of interactions that were had between fan and artist. Similar to Snapes, he points out the importance of this connection and how it has lasting effects on Harry’s discourse. I would say that both Snapes and Setoodeh are very credible sources. While they don’t have anything negative to say about their experiences with the music and at the concert, they do not have any negative contributions to his overall discourse. I would put them at a very slight bias in favor of Harry, but not enough to alter the state of his genre or discourse.
The final area that I wanted to cover in Harry’s discourse was regarding fashion. For this topic, I found two articles and one interview-style/recount article. For Vogue, Hamish Bowles recounts his day spent with Harry for his iconic cover of Vogue Magazine. Before diving into the themes, Hamish makes a point of providing a lot of context for the reader. He does so by giving a brief biography of Harry’s life and career. He also explains its relevance to the photoshoot that was taking place at the time. The article focuses on the main themes of Harry’s fashion lifestyle and some bits about Harry’s music. Hamish does a good job of ‘pulling back the curtain’ on the other major players that contribute to Harry’s discourse. He offers the fans a different perspective while simultaneously including Harry’s responses to each topic that he mentions.
The next article to mention fashion was Naomi Pike for British Vogue. Pike cover’s Harry’s appearance in the Gucci Beloved campaign while providing context to his fashion background and overall discourse. They make it a point to include brief information regarding his several other appearances that have been done with Gucci in the past.While this article provides a great deal of context, they are most definitely biased towards Harry with their positive language and compliments. In similarity, The New York Times also talked about Harry’s fashion in October. After interviewing fans on the street waiting for Harryween, Ruth La Ferla talks about their experience and costume choices. I found that this article provided the most important context regarding fashion in Harry’s discourse as it contains words from actual fans. They showcased photos of the fans’ costumes and accompanied them with brief interview questions. This allowed readers to understand the fan’s side of the concert experience. It also pulls everything full circle in regards to showing how Harry’s discourse has a direct impact on his fans. With first person accounts and photos to match, this article is very credible in contributing to Harry’s discourse.
While there is a lot of information regarding Harry Styles on the internet, I was able to find that album and concert reviews play some of the biggest parts in his discourse through this project. They provide the reader with real analyses about the quality of Harry Styles’ music on his own. They helped to develop the Rock/Soft Rock genres that were brought into the picture when he decided to move on as a solo artist. The concert reviews provide the other major half of this genre. Concerts and the experiences that they entail are an essential key to the discourse surrounding Rock in general. This aids fans in understanding the genre and enables them to highlight those aspects within Harry’s career. These reviews allow people to gain a new analytical perspective on why Harry’s musical talents are so well-respected and profound.
Similar to reviews, documentaries, interviews and fashion showcases also play a massive role in contributing to Harry’s discourse. However, I feel that they can offer a bit more in terms of context on Harry, as a person, rather than Harry, as a singer. The album and concert reviews thrive on a discussion that revolves around music, artistry, composition and vocals. The interviews, documentaries and fashion showcases thrive on a different conversation; one that revolves around gender fluidity, openness, vulnerability, creativity and life in general. They offer fans the chance to get an inside look at maybe Harry’s fashion choices, his experience writing an album, his thoughts on a performance, or his personal growth. They build the context of who he truly is for his discourse. I think that there is only so far the music will get you before you’re wanting to know even more about an artist, and these forms of media do a fantastic job of doing that. Through this project, I have been able to analyze each different form and piece together how they affect Harry’s discourse as a whole. Each of these outlets work together to create a masterful blend of the image of “Harry Styles”. They have been able to create a discourse that is surrounded around morals of openness, acceptance, vulnerability, and appreciation for Rock n Roll classics. All in all, each form of media allows the fans the chance to analyze, appreciate, and build the context of Harry’s life, career and success as a musician.